Examples of Crisis Management: Real Cases and What They Teach

The best examples of crisis management are not about a clever statement. They are about a decision, made early and under pressure, by leaders who knew what they were protecting. The worst examples are about a decision avoided.

I have spent more than 30 years in this work. Before founding Bryghtpath, I led global crisis management, business continuity, and intelligence at Target. Since 2014, our team has helped health systems, insurers, retailers, manufacturers, and technology companies build and test their crisis programs. The same patterns show up every time.

Below are six public crisis management examples, good and bad, three examples from our own client work, and the lessons your crisis team can use before its next activation.

Old View New View
Crisis management is mostly about the statement Crisis management is about the decision behind the statement
Wait until you have the facts Decide with partial facts, then refine as you learn more
If it wasn’t our fault, it isn’t our crisis If our customers feel it, it is our crisis
The crisis ends when the news coverage stops The crisis ends when operations recover and the lessons are fixed
Learn from the crisis after it happens Rehearse the hardest decisions before it happens

What Good Crisis Management Looks Like

Good crisis management is a capability, not a binder. It has four parts: a decision-making and communication framework, a trained crisis team with clear roles, decision rights your executives agreed to in advance, and practice. The plan matters less than whether your people can use it at 2 AM with half the facts.

Every example below either had those four parts working or was missing one of them. Our Ultimate Guide to Crisis Management covers how to build each one.

Six Public Crisis Management Examples

1. Johnson & Johnson and Tylenol (1982): Put people before the product

In late September 1982, seven people in the Chicago area died after taking Extra-Strength Tylenol capsules that someone had laced with cyanide. The tampering happened after the product left Johnson & Johnson’s control. The company could have argued that point. It didn’t.

Johnson & Johnson recalled about 31 million bottles, worth roughly $100 million at retail, and unveiled triple-sealed, tamper-resistant packaging on November 11, 1982. Tylenol’s market share fell from 37 percent to 7 percent, then recovered to about 30 percent within a year.

The lesson: Own the impact, even when you didn’t cause it. Customers judge you by what you do for them, not by whose fault it was. I cover Tylenol and two other turnarounds in more depth in our reputation management case studies.

2. Target and Hurricane Sandy (2012): Recovery speed is the scoreboard

When Sandy made landfall in New Jersey on October 29, 2012, I was running Target’s crisis management, business continuity, and intelligence team. Nearly 200 of our stores, several distribution centers, and two e-commerce data centers sat in its path.

Within 24 to 48 hours, we had ice, water, and recovery supplies at our stores. Through the retail trade association, retailers compared reopening rates, and we reopened faster than our competitors. As I said on Managing Uncertainty, Episode 285, that “gave us a multimillion-dollar advantage in revenue because we were open and they were not.”

It was a good response. Our after-action review still logged about 40 things that didn’t go well.

The lesson: Your board and your customers measure a crisis by how fast you serve them again. And even a strong response produces a long list of fixes. Write them down and close them.

3. KFC UK (2018): Apologize fast, even when a vendor caused it

In February 2018, KFC switched its UK delivery contract from Bidvest to DHL. Deliveries failed, and at one point 562 of its roughly 900 UK restaurants were closed. A fast-food chicken chain had run out of chicken.

KFC didn’t hide behind its new logistics provider. On February 23, it ran a full-page apology in The Sun and Metro: an empty bucket with the letters rearranged to read “FCK,” and a plain apology to customers who had traveled out of their way to find a closed restaurant.

The lesson: Two of them. Take responsibility for the customer experience, whatever the cause. And treat a switch in a critical supplier as a business continuity event, with a fallback ready before cutover day.

4. Pepsi (2017): A fast retreat beats a long defense

In April 2017, Pepsi released an ad in which Kendall Jenner ends a street protest by handing a police officer a can of Pepsi. Critics said it trivialized protest movements, including Black Lives Matter. Pepsi first defended the ad. Then, the next day, it pulled it: “Clearly we missed the mark, and we apologize.”

The lesson: When you are wrong, stop defending and fix it. But the real failure came earlier. The ad passed every internal approval. Build a step into launches where someone with authority asks, “How could this hurt us?”

5. Volkswagen (2015): The cover-up becomes the crisis

On September 18, 2015, the US Environmental Protection Agency notified Volkswagen that its 2.0 liter diesel cars carried software that detected emissions tests and cheated them. Days later, Volkswagen said about 11 million vehicles worldwide were affected.

The costs kept coming. In June 2016, Volkswagen agreed to US settlements worth up to $14.7 billion. In November 2016, it announced 30,000 job cuts at its namesake brand. In 2017, it pleaded guilty to three felony counts, including obstruction of justice, and agreed to $4.3 billion in criminal and civil penalties.

The lesson: No crisis process can rescue a decision to deceive. Tell the truth early, because the truth comes out anyway, and concealment turns a compliance failure into a criminal case.

6. Delta and the CrowdStrike Outage (2024): Same trigger, slower recovery

On July 19, 2024, a faulty CrowdStrike update crashed an estimated 8.5 million Windows devices. Airlines around the world were hit. Delta canceled thousands of flights over five days, its CEO put the cost at $500 million, and the US Department of Transportation opened an investigation into why Delta failed to recover as quickly as other airlines.

The lesson: Every airline had the same trigger. The difference was recovery. A crisis that starts in IT is decided by how well your business continuity and disaster recovery plans handle your dependencies, not by the outage itself.

Three Crisis Management Examples From Our Work

Our case studies are anonymized, but the outcomes are real.

A university that put a new framework to work

A for-profit university with a global presence brought us in for interim security leadership during its sale to private equity. We built its first-ever enterprise crisis management framework. That framework was then put to work during major hurricanes in 2016 and 2017, wildfires, and major protests. The university had minimal damage to property, rapid return to service for physical and online campuses, and no injuries or loss of life.

The lesson: One framework handles many kinds of crisis. A hurricane, a wildfire, and a protest need different actions, but the same team, the same decision process, and the same communication rhythm.

A global retailer after a major data incident

Following a major data incident, a global retailer based in the United States asked us to evaluate its business continuity, crisis management, and disaster recovery programs through our Resiliency Diagnosis® process, using ISO 22301 as the framework. We delivered a report, a maturity assessment, and a roadmap, and presented the findings to stakeholders, executives, and the board.

The lesson: The best time to fix a program is right after it has been tested for real. An honest outside review turns the pain of an incident into a funded roadmap.

A health insurer’s executives face a ransom decision

A major U.S. health insurer asked us to put its executives through a cyber-extortion exercise. In the scenario, a well-known ransomware group encrypted the insurer’s core claims processing system and issued an $18 million ransom demand, which was negotiated down to $8 million through a third-party firm. The executives decided whether to pay, how and when to notify members and regulators, and when to engage the board, while outside counsel played their real-life role.

The team reached a decisive outcome on the ransom question. The exercise also surfaced its next steps: a crisis communications playbook, a ransom-payment decision framework, and stronger executive access to business continuity impact data.

The lesson: The hardest crisis decisions should not be made for the first time during the crisis.

What These Crisis Management Examples Have in Common

Look across all nine and five lessons repeat.

  • Decide early. Johnson & Johnson and KFC acted before they had every answer. An executive team that waits for more information before activating is, as I said on Episode 334, “an ambulance just idling in the garage.”
  • Own the impact, whatever the cause. Tylenol was tampered with by a stranger. KFC’s shortage started with a vendor. Both companies took responsibility anyway.
  • Tell the truth early. Volkswagen shows what concealment costs. A crisis you disclose is a problem. A crisis you hide becomes a scandal.
  • Measure recovery, not just response. Target after Sandy and Delta after CrowdStrike faced events that many others faced too. Recovery speed is what separated them.
  • Rehearse, then fix what you find. The university, the insurer, and the Sandy after-action list all show it. Practice exposes gaps while they are still cheap to close.

How to Use These Examples With Your Crisis Team

Case studies are only useful if they change what your team does. Three ways to put them to work:

  • Run one as a discussion at your next crisis team meeting. Pick the example closest to your business. Ask: What would we know in the first hour? Who decides? What do we say first, and to whom? What do we restore first?
  • Turn one into a tabletop exercise. A critical supplier failing on cutover day, a technology outage that grounds your operations, a ransom demand on your core system. Build the scenario around your own dependencies, not the headline.
  • Write down your decision rights now. List the calls that belong to your crisis team and the ones reserved for your executives and board: a recall, a ransom payment, a store or site closure, a public apology. The executives and board section of our guide walks through how to set them.

Every organization in these examples had a plan of some kind. What separated them was the decisions their leaders made in the first hours, and whether they had practiced making them.

Keep Going

A few ways to go deeper if this was useful.

Bryan Strawser Avatar

About the author

Let’s build your Resilience Roadmap

Our team has spent two decades helping the world’s leading organizations prepare for and navigate disruption. We’ll bring that experience to yours.