When to Call a Crisis Communications Expert: A Guide to Hiring a Crisis PR Expert

The best time to hire a crisis PR expert is before the reporter calls. The second-best time is the first hour after. By the end of the first day, the story is already being written without you.

Most internal communications teams are good at what they do every day: launches, earnings, employee news. A crisis is a different job. It moves faster, it involves legal and regulatory exposure, and every word your organization says becomes part of the record. That is when an outside crisis communications expert earns the fee.

This guide covers when to make the call, what to expect from the person you call, and how to choose them before you need them.

Signs It’s Time to Call a Crisis Communications Expert

Call for help when one or more of these is true:

  • A journalist has your story and a deadline. Imagine a producer from a national news program calling about an executive you quietly let go for misconduct. They already know more than you think. You are in the race, and you are behind.
  • You have a cyber incident with notification obligations. A data breach or ransomware attack brings regulators, customers, employees, and possibly the attacker into the conversation, often on different clocks.
  • Someone was seriously hurt or killed. Workplace violence, a fatal accident, a product that harmed a customer. The communications have to be right the first time.
  • The crisis is about your leadership. Misconduct, a disputed decision, an activist campaign. The people who normally speak for the company are part of the story.
  • A story is spreading faster than you can respond. A viral post, misinformation about your company, or an internal rumor that has reached the outside.
  • Your team is about to be overwhelmed. The incident will run for days, and your communications team is three people who also have day jobs.

If you are debating whether to call, call. An experienced advisor can tell you in one conversation whether you need them for the next week or the next hour.

What an Outside Crisis Communications Expert Brings

Pattern recognition. Your team may face a crisis of this kind once in a career. A good crisis advisor has seen it many times. Rare events are routine to them, and they know what usually happens next.

Distance. Your people are worried about their colleagues, their company, and sometimes their own jobs. An outside advisor isn’t carrying that weight. As I put it on Managing Uncertainty, Episode 81, “We’re not in the basement.” That calm helps the room think.

Someone to say the hard thing. Inside the company, telling the CEO that the statement sounds defensive can be a career risk. An outside expert can say it plainly. “We can be the ones to say it. We’ll take the hit.” Often your leaders already know the right answer. They need confidence that it is the right answer.

Capacity. A serious crisis runs around the clock. Outside help lets your own team keep the rest of the business running.

Integration. The best advisors work alongside your outside counsel, your insurer, your incident response firm, and your crisis management team, so the message matches what the company is actually doing.

Hire a Crisis PR Expert, or a Crisis Communications Advisor?

Many organizations search for a crisis PR expert when what they need is broader. Both have a place.

Old View New View
Crisis communications is a PR problem Crisis communications is one part of crisis management
The goal is to control the story The goal is to be in the race and influence the story
A holding statement buys you a day or two A holding statement buys you minutes; updates have to follow on a schedule
The media is the main audience Employees, customers, regulators, and the board come first, or at least at the same time
Call the agency when the story breaks Line up the help, the messages, and the process before anything breaks

A PR agency with a crisis practice is strong on media relations, monitoring, and producing content at volume. Keep one on retainer if your exposure is mostly reputational.

A crisis communications advisor connects the message to the decisions. Many communications professionals lack the operational, regulatory, and adversary-timing experience a data breach demands. Your advisor should know what your crisis team is deciding, what your lawyers can and can’t say yet, when notification clocks start, and what your employees need to hear before the public does.

For a serious incident, you may need both. Make sure someone owns the connection between them.

What Good Crisis Communications Help Does in the First 24 Hours

  • Gets a holding statement out fast. What happened, who you are working with, your focus on the safety and well-being of the people affected, and when you will share more.
  • Tells employees first. Your people should never learn about the crisis from the news. Even ten minutes earlier matters.
  • Puts the right person at the microphone. The statement should come from a senior executive or the leader closest to the issue. From the communications department, it sounds like spin.
  • Refuses to lie, and refuses to go silent. “If you say nothing, then that will be the story,” and part of that story will be that you refused to comment.
  • Sets a cadence. A situational update after every crisis team meeting, and every message says when the next one will come.
  • Watches the internal rumor mill as closely as the outside narrative.

I talked through how these first hours unfold in Managing Uncertainty, Episode 18: The Race. As I said then, “The notion that you control the media is just utterly ridiculous. You can’t.” You can influence it, if you are in the race.

Questions to Ask Before You Hire a Crisis PR Expert

  1. Who will actually answer the phone at 2 AM? Get a name, not a promise. Ask what happens if that person is on another client’s crisis.
  2. What real crises have you worked in our industry? Healthcare, financial services, and other regulated industries have notification rules and regulators that change what you can say and when.
  3. How do you work with our crisis management team and our lawyers? You want someone who sits in the room where decisions are made, not someone waiting to be handed a decision to announce.
  4. Do you handle internal communications? Employees, managers, and the board need their own messages, sequence, and channels.
  5. Will you train our spokespeople and exercise with us before anything happens? A firm you have never practiced with is a stranger on the worst day.
  6. How do you bill? Retainer, incident rate, or both. Know the answer before you are negotiating in the middle of a crisis.

Better Yet: Line Them Up Before the Crisis

The calm, well-run crisis responses we see have one thing in common: the work started months earlier.

  • Pre-write messaging for your top risks. You can write most of it in advance. The holding statement for an active shooter incident is the same today as it will be in three days.
  • Build a rapid response process with fast approvals, inside your crisis management process, not beside it.
  • Put your outside advisors in your exercises. Outside firms sometimes expect to come in and run the show. Find out in practice, not in the middle of an incident.
  • Train the whole communications team, not just the spokesperson.

When a healthcare technology company’s new corporate communications leader asked us to review its crisis communications plan, we updated the plan through working sessions, trained the entire marketing and communications organization, and ran a social media simulation exercise with an After-Action Report (AAR). For more on building the foundation, see How to Build a Crisis Communications Strategy from Scratch and the HR and communications section of our Ultimate Guide to Crisis Management.

Our crisis communications services cover all of this: plan reviews, on-call advisory support, executive and board support, media training, and exercises.

You can’t control the story. You can decide whether you are in the race when it starts.

Keep Going

A few ways to go deeper if this was useful.

Bryan Strawser Avatar

About the author

Let’s build your Resilience Roadmap

Our team has spent two decades helping the world’s leading organizations prepare for and navigate disruption. We’ll bring that experience to yours.