, ,

Board Resilience: The Board’s Role in Business Resilience and Crisis Management

Board resilience is not about how the board weathers a crisis. It is about whether the board does its own job before, during, and after one, and stays out of management’s job while it does.

Most boards are unclear on that line. A 2026 survey by Deloitte’s Center for Board Effectiveness and the Society for Corporate Governance found that only 25% to 73% of companies, depending on company size and type, spell out board versus management responsibilities in their crisis plans. Even among large public companies, more than a quarter have not decided who decides.

Meanwhile, the questions are coming. As I said on Managing Uncertainty, Episode 285, “as the world has become more uncertain, your board is asking more and more questions about resilience than ever before.” Here is how to define the board’s role in business resilience, and how to help your board play it.

Old View New View
The board hears about resilience after something goes wrong The board gets a resilience briefing at least once a year, written into policy
The board approves the plan The board makes sure the plan is resourced, tested, and tied to strategy
In a crisis, the board weighs in on tactical calls In a crisis, the board backs management and makes only the decisions reserved to it
Board reporting means plan counts and compliance status Board reporting means outcomes: impact on people, recovery speed, and revenue
The board is briefed on exercises The board practices its own decisions in an exercise

Why Board Resilience Is a Governance Issue

The root of the board’s authority is simple. As I put it on Episode 310, the board picks your management, starting with the CEO. That makes crisis management and business continuity a governance issue, not an operational one.

The board does not run your resilience program. It makes sure one exists, that it is funded, that it is tested, and that it is aimed at the risks that could stop the company from reaching its strategic objectives.

One of the most important things a board can do is push management toward a clear definition of organizational resilience. Without one, every executive pictures something different: a recovered data center, a press statement, an insurance claim. A shared definition is what lets the board ask the right questions.

The Board’s Role in Business Resilience: Govern, Support, Assure

Every board role in resilience falls into one of three buckets.

  • Govern. Make sure the organization has a tested crisis management framework and plan, properly resourced and aligned with the enterprise risks of the organization. Ask whether your crisis posture matches your risk appetite.
  • Support. When a crisis hits, back the CEO and the executive team who are running the response. Approve the resources and decisions that require the board.
  • Assure. Show investors, regulators, customers, and employees that leadership takes disruption seriously. A visible, engaged board sends that message on its own.

Management runs the operation. The board governs, supports, and assures. When those lines blur, the response slows down.

Seven Board Responsibilities for Resilience

Inside those three buckets are seven specific responsibilities. I walked through them on Episode 224.

  1. Governance and oversight. Make sure crisis management, business continuity, and crisis communications capabilities and plans exist, and that they are reviewed and updated, not written once and shelved.
  2. Strategy and policy setting. Set the policies that guide how the organization prepares for, responds to, and recovers from a crisis. Make sure resilience is part of strategic planning, not just crisis response.
  3. Resource allocation. Approve the budget and people the program needs. A program with no resources is a policy, not a capability.
  4. Risk assessment and management. Usually owned by a risk, audit, or operations committee, sometimes with the chief audit officer or chief risk officer reporting to it directly.
  5. Crisis response and leadership. Support and guide the executive team during a crisis. The bigger the stakes, the closer the board gets. In a major cyber incident, expect the board to oversee parts of the response and recovery, and possibly approve management decisions.
  6. Communication and stakeholder management. In high-stakes situations, the board may speak with investors, regulators, or the public. When it does, it speaks in alignment with the CEO.
  7. Learning and development. After the crisis, review how the response went and make sure the lessons change the plans.

How much of this your board does depends on your size, your industry, your regulators, and the stakes of the crisis in front of you. Before founding Bryghtpath, I led crisis management at Target. There, the board was generally more informed about a crisis than consulted. Our chief security officer briefed the audit committee every year on business continuity and crisis management, and in some years my team presented to the full board.

What the Board Does in a Crisis, and What It Doesn’t

In a crisis, eyes turn to the board as well as the CEO. The board can be a steady hand, or a group that unintentionally complicates the response. The difference is whether it knows its lane.

The board supports management in four ways:

  • Trust and empower. Back the leaders who are in the arena. Don’t take over the playbook.
  • Enable resources. Approve the spending and decisions that require the board. A ransom payment over a set threshold is the classic example.
  • Advise and counsel. Bring the regulatory, investor, and reputational perspective, and the experience of directors who have lived through something similar. Advise, and leave the decisions to management.
  • Communicate strategically. Set expectations for transparency with outside stakeholders, in the same voice as the CEO.

And there are three traps I have seen boards fall into firsthand:

  • Running tactical decisions. What systems do we shut down? Which plants do we close? Who do we call first? That’s not the board’s lane.
  • Engaging only after the crisis hits. By then, the board’s best chance to help, making sure the organization was prepared, has passed.
  • Treating readiness as compliance. A clean audit tells the board the boxes were checked. It doesn’t tell them whether the executives can make the hard calls under pressure.

Write the decision rights down before you need them: what the crisis team decides, what is reserved to your executives, and what is reserved to the board.

What Good Board Reporting Looks Like

In 2012, Hurricane Sandy disrupted nearly 200 of our stores across New York, New Jersey, Pennsylvania, and other coastal areas. Our CEO briefed the board through the normal channels. My team gave him three things.

  • A simple timeline of what had happened.
  • The impact on our stores and our people. The most important question for us and for the board was not whether every store had reopened. It was whether anybody was hurt, including team members’ families as they sheltered, evacuated, and returned home.
  • A day-by-day reopening graph that compared our reopening rate with our principal competitors’, using data from an information exchange through our retail trade association.

The graph showed that we reopened faster than any of our competitors. Our business intelligence team then put a number on the difference: a multimillion-dollar revenue advantage, because we were open and they were not. We also kept our team employed and served communities that needed supplies to clean up and get back to work.

That is board reporting that works. It answers the board’s real questions in plain terms, and it shows that the investment in preparedness paid off. It is not a count of how many plans were updated last quarter.

Build that habit before the crisis. Write into policy a briefing to the board, or at least a board committee, on the state of your resilience program at least once a year.

Put Your Board in the Exercise

The board shouldn’t run exercises. But the board needs to make sure they happen, and in some cases it needs to practice its own role. If your board must approve ransom payments over a certain amount, practice that decision with the board before an attacker forces it.

When your program is mature enough, bring the board into a tabletop. Board exercises are not a test and not a briefing. Test the board and you lose them. Brief them and they tune out. Frame it as a rehearsal for a moment that could define the company’s reputation: “We’re not here to test your knowledge. We’re here to sharpen our collective judgment.” Keep it to a 45- to 90-minute strategic conversation, around a scenario the board actually worries about, such as cyber extortion, data exfiltration, a regulatory investigation, or executive misconduct. I covered the design in Episode 313: Running Exercises with Your Board of Directors.

Start with the executives if the board isn’t ready. When a major U.S. health insurer brought us in for an executive cyber-extortion exercise, its executive team made real-time decisions on whether to pay, how and when to notify members and regulators, and when to engage the board, with outside counsel playing their real role. The exercise surfaced the need for a ransom-payment decision framework, exactly the kind of decision a board may later be asked to approve.

Our executive and board exercises are built for that moment: the decisions only your executives and board can make, practiced before they’re real.

Questions Your Board Should Ask

If you sit on a board, stop asking whether the compliance boxes are checked. Your auditor will tell you that. Ask these instead:

  • When did the executive team last practice a cross-functional, enterprise-wide disruption?
  • What did we learn?
  • What changed as a result?
  • Who owns the decisions we struggled with last time?
  • Which decisions are reserved to this board in a crisis, and have we ever practiced making them?

If you lead resilience, have the answers ready before the board asks. Align your program to the organization’s strategic objectives, report outcomes the board cares about, and get on the calendar.

The board’s role in crisis management is not to run the response. It is to govern, support, and assure.

Keep Going

A few ways to go deeper if this was useful.

Bryan Strawser Avatar

About the author

Let’s build your Resilience Roadmap

Our team has spent two decades helping the world’s leading organizations prepare for and navigate disruption. We’ll bring that experience to yours.