Crisis Management Exercises: How to Improve Crisis Management Skills Before You Need Them

Your crisis team does not improve its crisis management skills by reading the plan. It improves them by using the plan, under pressure, in front of each other, before the real thing. That is what crisis management exercises are for.

Last year I started part-time paramedic school. In our skills week, I went five for five starting IVs on the training mannequins. Then I failed my first four attempts on a live classmate. I got the fifth, after I changed my technique. Knowing what to do and being able to do it under pressure are two different skills, and only one of them comes from practice. As I said on Managing Uncertainty, Episode 319, “we don’t just rise to the occasion, but rather we fail to the level of training that we have.”

Crisis teams work the same way. Here is how to build exercises that make your team better, not just compliant.

Old View New View
The exercise validates the plan The exercise builds the skills the plan depends on
Participants walk through a script Participants make decisions and live with them
Success means the team “did well” Success means the team found problems worth fixing
Test the scenario the plan was written for Test the scenario the plan never imagined
One exercise a year for the auditors A cadence where each exercise builds on the last

What Crisis Management Skills Actually Are

Crisis management skills are not knowledge of the plan. They are what your team does with the plan when the information is incomplete and the clock is running. Five matter most:

  • Deciding with partial information. You will never have all the facts in the first hours. The skill is making a defensible call anyway, and revisiting it as the facts change.
  • Knowing your role and your handoffs. Who decides, who advises, who executes. Most breakdowns happen at the handoffs, especially between the crisis team and your executives.
  • Communicating on a cadence. A situational update after every crisis team meeting, to everyone who needs it, with the time of the next update.
  • Managing outside pressure. The reporter on the phone, the regulator asking questions, the customer who heard about it first on social media.
  • Thinking past response to recovery. What do you restore first? What depends on what? The hardest decisions come after the first statement goes out.

Repetition turns those skills into muscle memory: clear roles, a steady communications rhythm, and faster decisions. You can’t get there from a binder.

Types of Crisis Management Exercises

Exercises run along a spectrum. Stress and realism increase as you move up. The US Department of Homeland Security’s Homeland Security Exercise and Evaluation Program (HSEEP) splits them into discussion-based exercises (seminars, workshops, tabletops, and games) and operations-based exercises (drills, functional exercises, and full-scale exercises). In the private sector, the useful versions are:

  • Walkthroughs and orientation sessions. Basic training. The team learns the plan and its roles before anyone is asked to perform.
  • Microsimulations. Short, self-run scenario discussions a business leader can run in under an hour without an expert facilitator. More on these in Using Crisis Microsimulations to Counter Crisis Fatigue.
  • Tabletop exercises. A facilitated discussion of a scenario that unfolds in moves. Tabletops build confidence and cohesion, and they are the right starting point for a new team or a new plan.
  • Functional or hybrid exercises. Teams receive real-time inputs by function and do part of the actual work, such as drafting the statement or making the staffing call.
  • Crisis simulations and full-scale exercises. Immersive, real-time, often multi-day, with partial information and injects through real channels. People write, publish, and decide, and their actions have consequences. This is where teams grow most.

Start where your team is. A new crisis team needs a confidence builder. A mature team that sails through every tabletop needs a challenge. If your tabletops have stopped finding new problems, you are ready for a crisis simulation.

How to Improve Crisis Management Skills with Exercises

These are the design rules we use. They come from running exercises for health systems, insurers, manufacturers, retailers, and technology companies.

1. Train before you exercise

Exercising a team that was never trained on the plan produces failure theater. The plan looks broken when the real problem is that leaders didn’t know how to use it, and you walk away with false lessons. Executive training can take as little as 60 minutes. I covered this on Episode 307: Why Training Before an Exercise Is Non-Negotiable.

Send objectives and prep materials 7 to 10 days out. “Bring the plan” is not preparation.

2. Force decisions, not discussion

A tabletop is a decision-forcing device. If your people spend the session listening instead of deciding, you bought a briefing, not an exercise.

Build each move around must-answer questions: who decides, by when, with what information. When the team stalls on missing facts, the facilitator says, “This is what we know. Assume this to be true. Move on.” That is the skill you are building.

3. Test novelty, not execution

The scenarios that break teams are rarely the ones in the plan. Too many programs exercise what is easy to simulate, not what would actually threaten the business. If every exercise on your calendar is a variation on ransomware, your team will hesitate when the crisis looks different.

Pick the scenario around the issue your organization is avoiding. Build it with your own subject matter experts, model it on things that have really happened to others, and keep it realistic. Avoid both extremes: the single network switch failure and the zombie apocalypse.

4. Make it feel real

Realism is what turns a discussion into practice. Use the channels your team will actually use:

  • Injects through real channels: email, text messages, Teams or Slack, voicemail, and phone calls.
  • Time pressure: decisions due at a set time, at the tempo of the threat, not the tempo of a meeting.
  • Outside pressure: a reporter calling for comment, a regulator’s inquiry, an angry customer, a social media post gaining traction.
  • Complications: new facts that contradict the first briefing, a second incident that competes for attention, a key person who can’t be reached.

When a leading Midwest health insurer brought us in for its first externally designed and facilitated crisis management exercise, we ran a three-hour, in-person tabletop with its crisis management team and sent real-time inputs through email, Microsoft Teams, and text messaging.

5. Make them sweat, safely

Make them sweat, at least a little. Stress reveals what a calm walkthrough hides. But put the stress on the process, not on individuals. Never design an exercise to embarrass your executives into action. That is an ambush, not an exercise, and it costs you the trust you need for the next one.

End the exercise in recovery, so people leave having worked through the crisis, not just the first hour of it.

6. Practice the handoffs

Plans rarely fail inside one team. They fail between teams: the incident team to the crisis team, the crisis team to your executives, your company to a critical vendor. Design moves that make those handoffs happen in the room, with real information passing between real roles.

7. Rotate your leaders

If your primary crisis leader runs every exercise, you have trained one person. Rotate the primary, backup, and tertiary leaders, and run some exercises with only the backups at the table. You want muscle across the bench.

Capture the Lessons or Lose Them

The exercise ends. The learning should not.

  • Run a hot wash right after the exercise, while memories are fresh. Open with “What did we see here today?”
  • Send an anonymous survey the next day.
  • Deliver the After-Action Report (AAR) within 7 to 10 days, with each recommendation assigned to a person, not a team, with a priority and a due date.
  • Retest what the last AAR said needed fixing in the next exercise.

The AAR is the only part of the exercise that outlives the afternoon. Our guide to conducting an effective after-action process walks through it.

The business case is simple. It is cheaper and easier to make mistakes in an exercise than in real life. In a real crisis, you want to make new mistakes, not the ones you already had a chance to find.

Build a Cadence, Not an Event

A single annual tabletop finds the same problems every year. Six months without an exercise, and your senior leaders are back to first principles at 2 AM.

A building-block cadence works for most organizations:

  • Crisis team tabletops at least twice a year.
  • Microsimulations for business teams between the larger exercises.
  • Lightweight simulations as the team matures.
  • A major simulation every one to two years.
  • Regular crisis team meetings, at least quarterly, where you talk through near misses that never triggered activation. Every meeting is a set of reps.

How to Build a Crisis and Business Continuity Exercise Strategy covers the building blocks in more detail, and the exercises section of our Ultimate Guide to Crisis Management covers formats and timing.

You don’t need a large budget to start. Our exercise options run from Exercise in a Box® ($1,799.99, 15 self-run scenarios) and Exercise in a Day® ($7,500, a custom tabletop built in one business day) to facilitated tabletop exercises starting at $25,000 and custom simulations for executive teams and boards.

Free Resources for Building Your Own Exercises

If you are building exercises in-house, these public resources are a solid foundation:

  • Ready.gov’s business exercise guidance explains walkthroughs, tabletops, functional, and full-scale exercises for private-sector organizations, and how to grow an exercise program over time.
  • HSEEP is written for government and multi-agency response, but its principles for exercise design, evaluation, and improvement planning translate well to large or multi-phase corporate exercises.
  • NIST Special Publication 800-84, the Guide to Test, Training, and Exercise Programs for IT Plans and Capabilities, covers testing, training, and exercising IT plans, including incident response and contingency plans. It dates from 2006, so pair it with current cyber scenarios.

Templates get you a scenario. Facilitation, realism, and follow-through are what build the skills.

We don’t practice until we get it right. We practice until we can’t get it wrong.

Keep Going

A few ways to go deeper if this was useful.

Bryan Strawser Avatar

About the author

Let’s build your Resilience Roadmap

Our team has spent two decades helping the world’s leading organizations prepare for and navigate disruption. We’ll bring that experience to yours.