Communicating with Stakeholders During a Crisis: Who Hears What, and When

Communicating with stakeholders during a crisis is where most responses win or lose their reputation. Not in the press release. In whether your employees, customers, franchisees, regulators, board, and the media each hear the right thing, from the right person, in the right order.

In almost every exercise, after-action review, and program evaluation we run, the same problem shows up: the organization has no single source of truth during the crisis. Information lives in text threads, side conversations, and long email chains. Executives tell us, even when they think the response went well, that what consumed the most time was understanding what was going on.

That is not a public relations problem. It’s an operational one. And it is fixable before your next crisis.

Old View New View
Crisis communication means the press statement Crisis communication is two jobs: operational and reputational
Tell people only what they need to know Inform as widely as sensitivity allows, to stop the rumor mill
Update stakeholders when there’s news Update on a published cadence, even when nothing has changed
The media comes first Employees, the board, and partners hear it before the media does
Write messages when the crisis hits Approve templates and holding statements in advance

Reputational Risks and Communications Strategies for Companies in Crisis

Crisis communication is two separate jobs, and most companies only plan for one.

Reputational communication is what your communications or public relations team does: statements, media, social media, and messages to customers and investors. It protects how the outside world sees you.

Operational communication tells your own people what is happening in the crisis, what the organization is doing, and what they need to do. It belongs to the crisis management team, not the PR team.

When operational communication fails, the reputational side fails with it. Employees who don’t know what’s going on post about it. Store managers improvise answers for customers. Franchisees call the press because nobody called them. Every inconsistent message becomes a second story.

Most crises also give you warning. The Institute for Crisis Management’s 2024 Annual Crisis Report found that nearly 75% of business crisis news coverage involved smoldering crises, problems that built over time, rather than sudden events. You usually have hours or days to start communicating before the story breaks. Use them.

Map Your Stakeholders Before the Crisis

Every crisis plan should have a stakeholder map: who needs to hear from you, what they need, who owns the message, which channel, and in what order. Here is how I think about the core groups.

Employees. They hear it from you first, before they read it online. People need to know they and their families are safe before they can focus on anything else. Tell them what happened, what it means for their work, and where to get updates. Every employee is a potential spokesperson, so give them the facts and tell them where to send media and customer questions.

Your executives and the board. Executives need the situational picture and the decisions only they can make. The board needs to know what’s happening and when it will be asked to weigh in. Don’t let the board learn about a crisis from the news.

Customers. Tell them how the crisis affects them: their orders, their data, their safety, their service. Customers care about impact, not your internal timeline. Give your customer-facing teams the same approved talking points at the same time.

Franchisees and other partners. Franchisees are your brand to the customer, but they don’t work for you, they don’t see your internal communications, and they’re running their own business. In a crisis they need three things fast: what happened, what you want them to do (and not do) in their locations, and who to call. Franchisee communication during a crisis gets missed more often than any other group, and when it does, the brand speaks with a hundred different voices. When we built a crisis management framework for a global quick service restaurant chain, franchisee reputational challenges were one of the reasons they started. Suppliers, distributors, and key vendors belong in the same category.

Regulators. Some notifications have legal clocks. A public company that determines a cybersecurity incident is material has four business days to disclose it to the SEC. Healthcare, financial services, and utilities have their own requirements. Know your clocks before you need them, and have Legal pre-approve the notification templates.

The media and social media. Say what you know, what you’re doing about it, and when you’ll update next. Don’t speculate. Don’t go silent. If you need a sense of when to bring in outside help for this part, I wrote about it in When to Call a Crisis Communications Expert.

Order matters. Stakeholder communication order is one of the findings that shows up again and again in our exercises. If a key customer hears about the crisis from a reporter, you’ve created a second crisis.

The Four Operational Communications Every Crisis Needs

I talked through these on Managing Uncertainty, Episode 243: Operational Crisis Communications. They are the backbone of communicating with stakeholders inside the organization, and they feed everything the PR team says outside it.

1. The monitoring alert. Not yet a crisis, but you’re aware and responding. I always called it the “keep your pants on email.” It says: this has happened; we’re assessing the impact (or here’s what we know); here’s what we’re doing; updates will follow; here’s who to contact with questions; no other action is needed right now. It stops people from inventing their own response to an issue you already have in hand.

2. The activation notice. The crisis management team has been activated. Here is what we know, who is leading, and when the first update will come.

3. The situational update. This is the most important communication you will send. Send it within an hour of each crisis management team meeting, and cover five things:

  • Current status of the situation
  • Actions taken since the last update
  • Status of the organization: sites, operations, people, and customers
  • Next steps
  • When the next update will come

Match the cadence to the velocity of the crisis. A fast-moving cyber event may need an update after every meeting. A slow-building supply problem may need one a day. Make it an email; it’s too long for a text message. Your mass notification tool can help deliver it.

4. The deactivation notice. The crisis is over, here’s where things stand, and here’s what happens next, including the after-action process.

Distribute these widely. As I said on the episode, “I am a big tent person when it comes to thinking about the communications audience.” Before founding Bryghtpath, our situational updates went to nearly every officer and director in the company, plus leaders in the impacted areas and every tier of the crisis structure. Informing people stops the swirl, stops the rumor mill, and gives them confidence in the response.

A consistent crisis management team meeting rhythm makes this cadence possible. See The Value of Consistent Crisis Management Team Agendas.

Prepare the Messages Before You Need Them

You won’t write good messages at 2 AM with Legal, HR, and the CEO all editing the same draft. Do the work in advance:

  • Templates for the four operational communications
  • Holding statements for your top scenarios, pre-approved by Legal
  • An approval path that takes minutes, not hours, tied to your severity levels
  • Contact lists for every stakeholder group, including franchisees, key customers, and regulators, kept current
  • Named roles: who approves, who speaks, who sends, and who keeps the communication log

The Ultimate Guide to Crisis Management lists what a strong crisis communications capability includes.

What Mishandled Stakeholder Communication Costs

BP, 2010. After the Deepwater Horizon explosion killed 11 workers and began the worst offshore oil spill in US history, BP’s CEO told reporters on the Louisiana coast, “I’d like my life back.” Families of the dead were still grieving. NPR later called BP’s handling a textbook example of how not to handle PR. The lesson isn’t that one executive misspoke. It’s that BP’s messages were written for BP’s audience, not for the people living with the impact. Our Deepwater Horizon case study walks through the full response.

Volkswagen, 2015. When the emissions cheating came to light, the concealment became the story. In June 2016 Volkswagen agreed to US settlements worth up to $14.7 billion. A crisis you disclose is a problem. A crisis you hide becomes a scandal, and every stakeholder you misled becomes a critic.

Practice It

Communications fail in exercises for the same reasons they fail in real events: no one owns the update, the approval path is too slow, and nobody remembered the franchisees. Build communications into every exercise. Have a reporter call. Make the team draft and send a real situational update under time pressure.

When a leading healthcare technology firm brought in a new leader for corporate communications, we reviewed and updated its crisis communications plan, trained the entire marketing and communications organization, and ran a social media simulation exercise followed by an After-Action Report (AAR). That sequence (plan, train, exercise, improve) is the one that works.

Then run an after-action review on how you communicated, not just on how you responded. Our guide on how to conduct an effective after-action process covers the method.

Your stakeholders will forgive a crisis. They won’t forgive finding out last.

Keep Going

A few ways to go deeper if this was useful.

Bryan Strawser Avatar

About the author

Let’s build your Resilience Roadmap

Our team has spent two decades helping the world’s leading organizations prepare for and navigate disruption. We’ll bring that experience to yours.